Do We Need to Give Up on Trends in Order to Take Sustainability Seriously?

Trends and sustainability are often considered mutually exclusive. Ethical fashion was historically accused of being too expensive and inferior in design; however, there's now an army of brands fighting to change this outdated perception. Reformation famously calls itself the next-best option after being naked, and Emma Watson is one of the most stylish women in the world, only wearing brands with an ethical mission statement. All this considered, do we need to give up on trends in order to take sustainability seriously? 

I can tell you now that there isn't a simple answer. Ethical fashion is complex—an initiative like H&M's recycling scheme is great, but it isn't going to solve anything overnight. Thinking more about our consumption, and taking steps (however big or small) is ultimately going to make a real difference. "Without a doubt, a change in mindset is what is needed," say Ella Grace Denton and Jemma Finch, the pair behind the clothes-swap initiative Stories Behind Things.

"We focus on fashion as something we can love and will also last—something that's timeless and not thrown away after just one wear," they continue. "Our focus should be on individual style and expression rather than mimicking trends. Style is about the individual. By buying into trends, we're simply buying into an industry's business model. By consuming fashion that's both meaningful and made in a way that aligns with our personal beliefs, what we wear becomes a true expression of the self."

Photo:

Shutterstock

Emma Watson has become the unofficial face of sustainable fashion.

Scandinavian designers are leaders in the sustainable sphere, and Rebecca Thandi Norman, editor of Scandinavia Standard, says that this is a response to the consumer demands in this region: "People here are concerned with sustainability as an aspect of everything, from food to furniture. Fashion is such a major part of consumer culture, so it follows that it needs to be taken into account when discussing sustainability. I also think that design is all about problem solving, and Scandinavians are very good at design in this way."

"If textile waste and water waste and unethical labor practices (and many other things) in the fashion industry are the problem, how do we begin to solve it?" she continues. "From a market perspective, consumers in Scandinavia are used to buying a few long-lasting things as opposed to many disposable things (which is not to say fast fashion isn't a big industry here—it is). They're also willing to pay for quality. Those are conditions you need if you're going to be successful as a sustainable fashion brand, so they've really been able to flourish here."

In the UK, we need to start behaving more like this Scandinavian consumer, really thinking about what we're buying, investing in quality pieces and questioning what we're wearing. Questioning things like the trend for PVC plastic handbags, for starters. This year, plastic pollution became a matter of urgent international concern, with a push to limit our use of single-use plastics. At the same time, however, plastic emerged as a key trend, thanks to cult items like Staud's PVC Shirley bag, Calvin Klein 205W39NYC's plastic-coated overcoat and Chanel's plastic bucket hats, with PVC handbags and shoes inevitably filtering down to the high street.

Photo:

Getty

One of the many plastic bags at fashion week this year.

Trisha Brown, Greenpeace Oceans campaigner, previously told Who What Wear that fashion's adoption of PVC is quite surprising: "Of all the different types of plastic in the world, PVC is the most environmentally damaging. PVC production facilities generate hazardous chlorinated wastes, some of which are inevitably released into the surrounding environment. Plus PVC often contains toxic additives such as phthalates, which are toxic to wildlife and humans." Stylist Rebecca Corbin Murray criticised the industry for glamorising virgin plastic, posting a picture of Céline and Burberry's plastic-bag handbags on her Instagram page, with the caption: "The disappointing swan song of two of the most beloved, innovative and iconic designers of our generation."

"I don't think it's possible to truly be trendy while also being sustainable," Norman argues. "A huge part of following trends is the constant consumerism, which is antithetical to sustainable dressing. Of course there are ways to get creative and continually change what you already have to match the trends. I think that's why people who try to dress more sustainably develop an individual style, or a uniform of sorts, that they're comfortable in from one year to the next. Of course, as the saying goes, 'Everything that's old becomes new again' in fashion, so the most sustainable way to dress on-trend is to buy second-hand or vintage."

View this post on Instagram

#ArizonaMusexTheEcoiste Arizona is wearing a Denim jacket by #Jeanerica. As one of the world’s leading sustainable denim brands, we love Jeanerica because the fabrics are all 13,5 oz denims of 98% organic cotton; GOTS certified organic cotton is grown without the use of synthetic agricultural chemicals such as fertilisers or pesticides and grown without genetically modified seeds. Organic cotton is mainly grown in rain fed systems (80%). Its cultivation in rotational agricultural systems instead of monocultures enhances the soil, resulting in increased organic matter, meaning water is retained more efficiently. The fabrics are made by premium denim weaver Isko from Turkey where the denims are also produced at their own facilities. The rest of the manufacturing is in Albania and Italy, with washing and finishing made at famous wash house Washitalia. Earrings, #LilianVonTrapp We love Lilian’s eponymous brand largely because of her commitment to only using 100% certified recycled gold. All production takes place in Germany, Dietrich in Pforzheim, using only Gold bought from German company Bauer-Walser. Bauer-Walser is a gold refinery that specializes in recycling gold that has already been in circulation (such as gold components, jewellery or electronics). They are independently audited and certified by the Responsible Jewellery Council (RJC). The audit certifies, that indeed 100% of the gold that comes from the refinery Bauer-Walser has been recycled by them (as opposed to bought from mines and refined fresh). ???? @philltaylormade • Make-up @amanda.grossman using all natural and organic products • Hair by @johnmacphersonhair • Sustainability Intel by The Sustainable Angle @thesustainableangle

A post shared by The Ecoïste (@the.ecoiste) on

Isabel, Who What Wear's social media editor, is my daily reminder that trends and sustainability aren't mutually exclusive. She can spot a micro-trend faster than anyone I know, and wears the beaded bags, hair clips and fun accessories you see all over Instagram, but she thinks about every single purchase she makes. "The biggest myth is that shopping sustainably means only buying expensive things that are 'made sustainably,'" she tells me. "While there are tons of amazing brands offering beautiful pieces at higher (but fair trade) price points, shopping sustainably also means two more options. One, think twice before buying something—choosing not to buy something is shopping sustainably. When you do decide to buy anything, take care of it, mend it, and love it. And two, try to avoid buying new."

There are so many sources to investigate and shop from in comparison to a year ago, but here are a few good starters: We'd suggest checking out @theecoiste on Instagram, plus online shops including Gather & See, Antibad StoreNoa Vee and see our edit of sustainable pieces to buy now (and keep forever) below…

Shop Sustainable, Trend-Led Pieces

These are vegan, produced in limited quantities in L.A. and even feature deadstock metal buckles.

MOP's "No Frills" collection has a more transparent manufacturing chain where you can trace the garment from field to its final form.

These are Emma Watson's trusted trainers.

This is a hard-working, organic and Fair Trade piece that doubles up as a jacket.

For all its mass production, Zara is attempting to enter a more sustainable market with its Join Life collection. These trousers are made from Tencel: A fabric that is "made from wood grown in sustainably managed forests that guarantee their reforestation and is produced in a closed cycle that is environmentally and water friendly."

Cat Bird is one of Emma Watson's favourite sustainable jewellery brands.

This is another Emma Watson–approved brand. 

Stella has crafted these sneakers without glue to attached the sole to the upper. This means you can, one day, take them apart and recycle each part individually.

These pieces prove that dressing sustainably isn't so terrifying.

Opening Image: Lucy Williams

This piece was published at an earlier time and has since been updated.