These 11 Red Nail Polishes Are Perfect, According to Our Editors

Whether you're a burgundy gal, a true-red devotee or someone who is more partial to a pinky shade of raspberry, it's fair to say that red is the most classic nail colour there is. In our experience, it also seems to be a particular favourite of the fashion girl—a relatively rare breed in the world of beauty and the sort of person who tends to stick to classic colours and versatile, low-key finishes.

With this in mind, we decided to turn to our editors to test our theory, and lo and behold, they all had tried-and-tested faves when it came to red nail polish. With a super-easy red nail being one of the best beauty-related ways to boost your mood and make you feel great, what more reason do you need to treat yourself to a new polish? 

So without further ado, we present to you the 11 red nail polishes that come editor approved. We've done the testing so you don't have to. Scroll down to see our shortlist.

Shannon Lawlor, Freelance Beauty Editor

"When it comes to my own beauty habits, there are very few things that I refuse to tolerate. Lipstick on teeth is one; dry feet in summer sandals is another. The one that frustrates me the most, however, is chipped red nail polish. If my red varnish has even the slightest inconsistency in just one place, it's game over for every single nail. It's important to me, therefore, that any formula I settle on is long-lasting and reliable. It has to be glossy and pigmented, bright and poppy, orange-toned but not coral and more or less bulletproof. Is that really so much for a beauty editor to ask?"

Best Red Nail Polishes: Nell Block

Photo:

@NELLBLOCK

"For years, I've only worn two colours on my nails: red or a deep cherry colour. This means that I've spent a lot of time hunting down the perfect red polish, which is surprisingly hard. Some are too orange, others too purple, but what I'm really looking for is a hue as close to a postbox colour as possible. There are three brands I've found that meet my strict criteria: H&M, Nails Inc. and Essie. One final piece of advice is to always make sure you use a topcoat (my all-time favourite is Seche Vite), as it'll give your nails a real lacquered finish."

Joy Montgomery, Shopping Editor

Best Red Nail Polishes: Joy Montgomery

Photo:

@JOY_MONTY

"Despite not being the biggest beauty buff in the world, if there's one thing that is guaranteed to lift my mood, it's a manicure—particularly when I've treated myself to one at home. I tend to stick to classic shades, one of which has to be red. For a long time, I favoured deeper burgundy hues, but recently, I've come around to the appeal of a brighter true red."

Maxine Eggenberger, Acting Assistant Editor

"For someone who spends an inordinate amount of time discussing beauty, admittedly, I have zero interest in painting my nails. I am, however, very into shellac and gel, which I have perfectly applied by a talented nail technician who has ruined DIY manis for me. Call me predictable, but I tend to flit between two shades: CND's Wildfire and The Gel Bottle's Candy. Although bright and bold, they feel—to me anyway—like very grown-up, classic shades of red.

"However, there is one nail polish I have at home on standby, and that's Chanel's Le Vernis Rouge Essentiel. The colour pay-off is incredible—it only needs two coats—and I really like the contrast of the deeper shade against the alabaster colour of my skin. It lasts better than any other polish I've tried and became my beauty lifeline during lockdown. So although it'll never compare to my technician, Shelly, it's a strong second."

Related Stories