I Tried on 30 Pairs of Black Leggings, and These Are the Very Best

My quest for the best black leggings was an unexpected one. I've never been one for the stretchy pants, but upon seeing how much everyone else depends on and obsesses over them—not to mention the fact that stylish girls are now using this outfit combination IRL—I thought it time to investigate. As a woman who wouldn't be caught dead in a pair outside the house (even the sad-looking ones inside my house should be arrested for crimes against fashion), I found this quest was about finding not only the best black leggings but also the versions that are good enough to convert a self-confessed leggings hater. What I was looking for? Leggings that lift and skim and do wonderful things to my otherwise not-so-wonderful legs.

It's all well and good being Kendall Jenner, flinging on any pair of flimsy black leggings and having automatically cracking pins, but when you're not made of supermodel stuff, which stretchy super-pants really do the trick? I tried on loads—some incredible, some shockingly unflattering, and some really expensive (heading well into the £300 arena), but I avoided the really cheap versions as a rule. There's no denying you need some fabric tech and a certain level of quality to wear leggings in public feeling confident that they won't go sheer when you bend over or fall apart in the wash after one cycle. So, after my extensive trials, I can confirm that the following black leggings are the best in the business—and each pair excels in a different way, meaning you can locate the style (or styles) that fulfill your deepest black-legging desires. Read my reviews and shop the winning leggings below.

Best black leggings for work:

These are somewhere between treggings and leggings, and that slightly more structured fit makes them 100 times more appropriate for a work environment. The ankle-grazing length hits just at the right point to show off a posh pair of pumps. 

Best black leggings for going straight out after the gym:

It's the super-soft fabric (Full-On Luxtreme) that still looks brand-new—even after a year of wear. These leggings also offer great support and coverage. They have a high-waisted, super-flattering stomach panel that really helps to create the coolest workout-to-going-out leggings of them all. This silhouette is a signature of the brand's, so you can find them in different colours and patterns too.

Best black leggings for bloated days:

Don't be scared, Spanx has an array of leggings to choose from with different levels of compression, each claiming to "shape" and "hug" rather than, erm, cut off your circulation. And the "Look At Me Now" style is the brand's best-selling. Boasting a double-layer, high-rise waistband which acts as a clever tummy-flattening panel, and could be considered very beneficial on a bloated day.

Best black leggings for a night out:

I found that the common thread throughout the chosen black leggings in this story is that they all share hidden, thick elastic waistbands. Winser London is no exception. These have a slight sheen to them, which made me more inclined to wear them after dark. I'd recommend you size down by one or two to avoid a saggy back-of-the-knee and under-bottom. So instead of my usual 12, I'd (happily) opt for an 8.

Best treggings on a budget:

H&M's basic black leggings are favoured by fashion insider like Natasha Ndlovu of Natasha Bisous, but they're also a bit of a secret source for quality cut-price treggings. Also, it's excellent that they tend to go up to a size 18 or 22 in most iterations.

Best leather leggings:

Joseph's top-notch leather goods have a solid reputation in the industry, and it's the slimming, pull-on, elasticated-waist classics that have fashion girls investing in a pair for life. They're pricey, yes, but if you're a leather-trouser girl through and through, it's a cost-per-wear calculation you should make.

Scroll Through to Shop More of Our Favourite Black Leggings

Another option for fashion fans looking for a smart (and stylish) legging option.

Perfect for your workout or for wearing with chunky knits, these leggings feature compressive technology for added support.

We know, we know, these are more than we'd usually spend on something so casual, but these luxurious leggings from The Row promise a super-sculpting, second-skin fit.

To ensure a great fit on the waist, look for styles with an elasticated band.

Looking for something slightly cropped? Try Wolford for the chicest (and cosiest) ankle-grazing option.

While some cheap leggings can be unflattering, you can't beat ASOS for its high-rise, super-soft option that comes in at just £8.

Perfect for yoga, of course, but also good for the daytime too. 

Now that you've found your perfect black leggings, see how fashion editors would suggest you wear them

This post was originally published at an earlier date and has since been updated.

Related Stories